Has this ever happened to you?
You’re out to dinner with friends (none of whom are writers), and everyone’s answering the question, “What have you been up to lately?” Your friends talk about their jobs or upcoming trips, and then it’s your turn to answer.
Excitedly, you begin to explain how your blog is growing and that you’ve been asked to guest post. Or you tell them that you’re in the midst of plotting your new novel.
Then you get that look. You know the look. The bored look that’s usually followed by, “That’s cool.” And then they quickly change the subject.
You feel slightly disheartened. But you’re used to it by now.
You’re a writer, and you’ve come to learn that seldom do non-writers share your passion. Your friends might be supportive of your writing endeavors, but they don’t really understand what you’re doing.
What’s a writer to do? Though you love writing, it can sometimes feel a little lonely.
You’d love to have some friends to bounce ideas off of, who could help you brainstorm new strategies for getting your first 1,000 email subscribers, who could read your latest story and suggest how you can fix that glaring plot hole.
Many writers have been in the exact same situation as you. Their solution?
They do what C.S. Lewis did when he created The Inklings. They form a mastermind group with fellow writers.
When I started this blog back in 2016, I was desperate to find friends and colleagues who shared my passion for blogging and writing. Then the opportunity came.
I was participating in an online coaching program for bloggers with a bunch of very cool people. The other students and I decided to form a mastermind group, and since then, we’ve been meeting every other week to set goals, keep each other updated on our projects, and provide each other feedback.
Not only do I not feel alone anymore, but the group has also provided me with additional accountability as I pursue my blogging and writing goals.
Often during a mastermind conference call when I express my discouragement over a blogging project, it turns out someone else in the group is facing similar struggles. Because of our shared experience, we can sympathize with each other, support each other, and encourage each other. And the members of the group are always there to offer me lots of new ideas and blogging strategies to try.
If you want to grow as a writer and are looking for encouragement and accountability, I highly recommend starting a mastermind group.
Read on to discover what exactly a mastermind group is, more about the Inklings and several other mastermind groups of famous writers, and three of my tips for how you can start your own mastermind group.
What is a Mastermind Group?
The word “mastermind” was coined by Napoleon Hill in the 1920s and later popularized in his book Think and Grow Rich. Hill argued that when two people come together to solve a problem, their combined wisdom forms a “master mind”. He urged budding entrepreneurs to form mastermind groups (or “alliances”, as he called them) where they could keep each other accountable to their goals and give each other advice about their projects.
I’m not a fan of Hill’s books, but I do like his term “mastermind”. There’s something special that happens when everyone in the group puts their heads together and helps brainstorm how to solve a member’s problem. As Proverbs 15:22 says,
Without counsel plans fail, but with many advisers they succeed.
Indeed, while Hill may have coined the term, mastermind groups have been around for a long time. Writers throughout the centuries have recognized the importance of meeting with other serious writers to discuss their work, collaborate, and help each other improve their craft.
Famous Writers Who Formed Mastermind Groups
The Inklings is one of the best-known writers mastermind groups. Headed by C. S. Lewis and J. R. R. Tolkien, the group gathered on Thursday evenings at Lewis’s rooms in Magdalen College. Later on, they would also meet for lunch at a local Oxford pub called The Eagle and Child.
The members of the group came together to share ideas and receive feedback on the latest drafts of their novels. Tolkien, for example, read aloud from a manuscript that would eventually become The Lord of the Rings.
C. S. Lewis’s brother, Warren, observed,
We were no mutual admiration society: praise for good work was unstinted, but censure for bad work – or even not-so-good work – was often brutally frank.
By receiving an outside opinion on their work, the writers were able to rewrite passages and develop their story ideas even further. If a story had stalled and they weren’t sure how to continue, the other members could suggest new plot twists and encourage them to keep pressing forward with their writing.
C. S. Lewis said of his fellow Inklings members, “What I owe to them is incalculable.”
Here are several more famous writers groups:
- The Junto (also known as The Leather Apron Club): A group of friends organized by Benjamin Franklin that was dedicated to “mutual improvement”. Not all of the members were writers by profession, but they were all required to present essays they had written on topics of their choosing.
- The Bloomsbury Group: An influential group of writers, including E. M. Forster and Virginia Woolf, who all lived and worked near Bloomsbury, London.
- The Dymock Poets: A group of poets that included Robert Frost. They published their own quarterly called New Numbers.
- The Algonquin Round Table: A group of New York City writers, artists, and actors including Dorothy Parker and George S. Kaufman who met at the Algonquin Hotel from 1919 to 1929.
Clearly, these writers knew that there was strength in numbers.
Three Tips for Starting Your Own Mastermind Group
If you want to start your own mastermind group, here are three tips:
1. Find the Right People
The members are the most important element of a successful mastermind group. Everyone should be serious about improving their craft and be committed to showing up to the meetings.
It’s also usually best if your members all have a similar level of experience (or if each member has a particular area of expertise). That way you can all challenge and learn from each other.
Additionally, you want members that you can trust and confide in as you will be sharing your struggles and your in-progress work.
You don’t need to have a large group. Small groups are probably better as you will have more time to devote to giving feedback to each member. You could even start your group with only one other person.
Where to find members for your mastermind group? You could start with your circle of friends or reach out to your professional network or even fellow writers you’ve met online (as I did). For example, you can join my private Facebook group to connect with other writers.
2. Determine how & how often you will meet
It’s important to determine whether you’ll meet in person or online. Naturally, this will be an easy decision if some of your members live out of state or even in another country.
However, even if all of your members live within driving distance, it’s a good rule of thumb to choose the most convenient option for everyone. Meeting online might still be more feasible with everyone’s schedules. This will give your mastermind group a greater chance of success.
My mastermind group meets online through a video conferencing software called Zoom. We can either join the meeting through our computers or call in with our phones. Skype and Google Hangouts are two other platforms you can use to hold meetings online.
Once you’ve agreed on how you’ll meet, it’s critical to determine what time and how often. My group holds our meetings on the same day and time every other week. You might want to choose every week or just once a month. But, above all, pick a consistent day and time that people can commit to in advance.
And be prepared to work hard to keep your group alive, especially in the first several months. Groups often die if no one takes the initiative to follow up and reschedule missed meetings.
3. Have a planned structure for your meetings
Planning out the structure of your meetings in advance will help you make the most of the time you have. My group usually begins with each member giving us an update on his or her projects and sharing a success. Then one member will be able to request the “hot seat” and get help with brainstorming how to overcome a specific struggle.
My current mastermind group doesn’t focus on critiquing each other’s writing. However, I have been part of mastermind groups where we gave each other feedback on our fiction writing, and we followed a similar structure to the one above.
Regardless of how you structure your meetings, I recommend having one member facilitate the meeting, keep track of time, and make sure everyone stays on schedule.
Writing can be a lonely activity. Mastermind groups give writers a sense of community and a sense of belonging.
You’re surrounded by fellow writers who have faced the same struggles as you and can share their wisdom and encouragement. They will make sure you stay on track to complete your projects, that you continue sharpening your skills, and that you don’t give up on your dreams.
Are you part of a mastermind group? Or would you like to start one? Let me know in the comments.
And if you found this post helpful, please share it with a friend. You can use the picture below to share it on Pinterest.
Did you enjoy this post? Get the free eBook!
Join the mailing list, and as a special welcome gift, I'll send you a free copy of my eBook "Famous Writers' Productivity Hacks". You will also get my latest posts about how to hone your craft (+ more writing inspiration not shared on the blog) delivered straight to your inbox.
Thank you for this post. I have been in Masterminds before and they were incredibly helpful in achieving my goals. My mastermind group disbursed long ago and I miss the sharing, caring and accountability of like-minded people.
S Crawford says
Something I’ve realized as I get older is how much of an impact the people I surround myself can have on my productivity. Being able to brainstorm, collaborate, and be immediately accountable to others is a big help in turning ideas into projects and projects into finished work.
Nicole Bianchi says
So true! 🙂 Thanks for reading and commenting.
This is so me! I think my friends try to be supportive, but they don’t really understand what blogging is or what it all entails. I don’t have any blogger friends but starting a mastermind group is an amazing idea to help overcome that and remain motivated. I didn’t even realize that so many famous authors had started their own!
Nicole Bianchi says
Hi, Christina! 🙂 Thank you for reading and commenting. I hope you are able to meet other bloggers who you can form a mastermind group with. Facebook groups are a great place to start to find other bloggers.
“The members are the most important element of a successful mastermind group. Everyone should be serious about improving their craft and be committed to showing up to the meetings.”
This is soooooo true, Nicole.
It sounds like you were able to connect with the right people in the formation of your group.
How were you able to do so?
Nicole Bianchi says
Hi, Jathan! Thanks for commenting. 🙂 The members of my mastermind group and I were all students in one of Jeff Goins’s coaching programs. We decided to create a mastermind group so we could keep each other accountable outside of the coaching program. If you’re a member of any kind of writer’s meetup or online course, I think that’s a great place to look for people who might be interested in forming a mastermind group.
Anne Peterson says
I think this is the first time I’ve been in a mastermind group. If you could even say I’m in. Not quite sure how much time it really takes, and I’ve been divided in many different directions. I did enjoy this article a lot and I thought you clearly outlines what a mastermind group is, how it can be effective and you mentioned others who utilized it sharing how it benefited them. Thank you.
Nicole Bianchi says
Hi, Anne! 🙂 Thank you for reading and commenting. I think the amount of time will depend on each mastermind group. Sometimes it’s fine to just meet once a month. I’m so glad to hear you found the article helpful.
I’ve done a mastermind group before and they were amazing. Who is in the group is definitely important. If everyone is equally determined to grow and enthusiastic the energy is amazing! I’d love to start one again and find other writers. Would be great if you started one Nicole!
Nicole Bianchi says
Hi, Francesca! Thanks for your comment. 🙂 Yes, I love the energy in mastermind groups. I always feel so inspired and motivated after each meeting. Hope you are able to start one again soon.
Tanya de Kruijff says
What a great idea. It does get lonely sometimes. I love working without any colleagues, but at the same time I miss them whenever I’d like to consult someone about my work.
Nicole Bianchi says
Thanks so much for your comment, Tanya! 🙂 Yes, I too prefer working independently rather than in a group, but (like you said) there comes a time when it’s necessary to get other people’s suggestions and opinions, especially if we want to improve as writers.